La pandemia de la covid-19, la fuerza mayor y la alteración de las circunstancias en materia contractual / The covid-19 pandemic, force majeure and changed contractual circumstances / A pandemia da covid-19, a força maior e a alteração das circunstâncias em matéria contratual

La declaratoria del estado de emergencia, a causa de la pandemia de la covid-19, exige un análisis de la vigencia de las relaciones contractuales y cómo estas pueden verse afectadas por eventos extraordinarios, imprevisibles e irresistibles que impidan el cumplimiento de las prestaciones, así como aquellos casos en los que la alteración de las circunstancias puede llevar a que una de las partes exija al juez recomponga el contenido de la prestación pactada o la resolución del contrato.

The declaration of a state of emergency due to the covid-19 pandemic requires an analysis of the validity of the contractual relations and how these may be affected by extraordinary, unforeseeable and irresistible events that prevent the performance of the services, as well as those cases in which the alteration of circumstances may lead one of the parties to demand that the judge recompose the content of the agreed service or terminate the contract.

A declaração de estado de emergência, devido à pandemia da covid-19, exige uma análise da vigência das relações contratuais e como estas podem ser afetadas por eventos extraordinários, imprevisíveis e irresistíveis que impeçam o cumprimento das prestações, assim como aqueles casos em que a alteração das circunstâncias podem levar a que uma das partes exija que o juiz recomponha o conteúdo da prestação acordada ou a rescisão do contrato.

El papel de la Corte Constitucional en el análisis de los contratos de medicina prepagada / The role of the Constitutional Court on the analysis of contracts of prepaid medicine programs

RESUMEN A partir del año 1991, con el establecimiento de la actual Constitución Política colombiana y la designación de la Corte Constitucional como guardiana y protectora de la misma, los valores constitucionales han permeado todas las materias y áreas del derecho, inclusive aquellas que se entendían dispuestas a la autonomía de la voluntad de los particulares. El contrato de Medicina prepagada es un buen ejemplo de este fenómeno en la medida en que la Corte Constitucional colombiana, mediante sentencias de revisión de tutela, con la intención de proteger el derecho a la salud y reprender las conductas contrarias al principio de buena fe, ha limitado la libertad contractual de particulares -empresas de medicina prepagada-, en beneficio del usuario de este servicio. Esta protección se ha realizado imponiendo a las empresas obligaciones y cargas de verificación del estado de salud del paciente y prohibiendo la inclusión de cláusulas generales de preexistencias y exclusiones en los contratos. Sin embargo se encuentra un vacío en lo referente al deber de los usuarios de actuar de buena fe.(AU)

ABSTRACT Since 1991, when the current Colombian Constitution came into force and the Constitutional Court was appointed as its guardian and protector, constitutional values have permeated all subjects and areas of law, even those that were previously considered as private matters. Prepaid medicine contracts are a good example of this phenomenon, since the Colombian Constitutional Court has limited individual freedom of contract to private parties -prepaid medical companies- for the benefit of final users of this service through "acción de tutela", in order to protect the right to healthcare and to prevent some behaviors that violate the principle of good faith. The Court has demanded private companies to assess the health condition of patients and has prohibited pre-existent and exclusion clauses that diminish the responsibilities of said companies. Nevertheless, there is a gap in the law regarding the duties of good faith that concern the user, which will be addressed in this paper.(AU)

Neoliberalismo en salud: La tortura de trabajadoras y trabajadores del Instituto Materno Infantil de Bogotá / Neoliberalism in health: the torture of the health care workers of the Bogota s Instituto Materno Infantil (child and maternity hospital)

Objetivos Relacionar históricamente las transformaciones más significativas del Instituto Materno Infantil (IMI) en su proceso de crisis, cierre y liquidación con las experiencias de sus trabajadores/as. Encontrar elementos vivenciales y teóricos que interconecten el proceso de privatización de la salud con las experiencias de resistencia y dolor/sufrimiento de trabajadores/as. Métodos Etnografía inscrita en corrientes críticas y apoyada en trabajo de campo constante y colectivo, investigación histórica (fuentes primarias y secundarias) y entrevistas semiestructuradas con cinco mujeres que trabajaron por más de quince años en el IMI. Resultados Una línea del tiempo con cuatro periodos principales: Los años de gloria (hasta 1990), Llega el neoliberalismo (1990-2000), La crisis y las resistencias (2001-2005) y Liquidación (2006-). La narrativa de las mujeres entrevistadas devela múltiples agresiones que se intensificaron desde el 2006 generando dolor/ sufrimiento, relatos que ilustran violaciones a sus derechos humanos y laborales. Discusión Proponemos analizar las conexiones entre los diferentes tipos de violencia y el dolor/sufrimiento bajo la categoría tortura, entendida como acciones violentas que causan dolor físico-emocional, las cuales son ejecutadas por actores de poder sobre otros que desafían alterarlo. Enfatizamos en las burocracias, el confinamiento, los agentes torturadores y los resquebrajamientos a la unidad mente/cuerpo para argumentar que esta relación neoliberalismo y tortura pretende eliminar los últimos trabajadores/as de la salud del país con garantías laborales para avanzar en la acumulación de capital que genera la creciente sobreexplotación del trabajo y la mercantilización de la salud.

Objectives To link, from a historical point of view, the most significant transformations of the Instituto Materno Infantil (IMI) [the oldest child and maternity hospital of the country] during its process of crisis, closure and liquidation with the experiences of the hospital workers. To find experience-based and theoretical elements that can interconnect the process of health care privatization of the country with the workers' experiences of resistance and pain/suffering. Methods Critically-oriented ethnography based on continuous collective field work, historical research (primary and secondary sources) and semi-structured interviews with 5 women who worked at the IMI for more than 15 years.Results: A time line of 4 main periods: Los años de gloria [The golden years] (up to 1990); Llega el neoliberalismo [Neoliberalism arrives] (1990-2000); La crisis y las resistencias [Crisis and resistances] (2001-2005); and Liquidación [Liquidation (2006-20??)]. The narratives of the interviewed women unveil multiple aggressions that have intensified since 2006, have caused pain and suffering and are examples of violations of human and labour rights. Discussion We suggest to analyze the links between the different kinds of violence and pain and suffering as torture. This category is defined as the set of violent actions that cause physical and emotional pain, which are performed by actors in positions of power over other people who challenge that power and are part of modern States' ideological principles around a defined moral social order. For the IMI workers' case, the ideological principle that is being challenged is health care neoliberalism. From the analyses of bureaucracy, confinement, torturing agents, and the breaking-off of the body-mind unit we conclude that this relationship between neoliberalism and torture aims to eliminate the last health care workers of the country who had job stability and full-benefits through public labour contracts. Their elimination furthers the accumulation of capital generated by increasing over-exploitation of labour and commodification of health care.

Legal nature of the surrogate contracts

Infertility is a problem for couples throughout the world. One solution is surrogate motherhood. A typical surrogate mother contract involves three parties: a man and a woman who, as a couple, want to employ the services of a surrogate mother, and another woman who agrees to conceive a child through artificial insemination with the couples' embryo. Usually, in return for a sum of money, the surrogate mother agrees to bear the child and give it to the couple after pregnancy. The infertile couple agrees to pay the surrogate mother a fee, as well as medical expenses and cost of travel. Furthermore, they agree to accept custody of the child. Other clauses of the contract may include: the surrogate mother's promise not to form or attempt to form a relationship with the child; limitations on the surrogate mother's rights to smoke, drink, or have intercourse. Surrogacy is one of the methods in assisted reproduction technology in invitro fertilization. Using this method is not limited to the hysterectomized or women without womb. Ambiguity in the nature of surrogate contract is one of the obstacles to contract enforcement. Therefore recognition of Nature of this contract is important. Nature of this contract has not contained in a specific shape of agreement like lease, borrowings and contract of rewards etc. And can only be admitted on the basis of code 10 of civil law, but all the signs of contract'cannot be ascertained on the basis of the wills of two parties and a portion of it will be settled on vindicating impressions. The most important sign are relationship and parentage from contract which will be obtained as non-voluntarily and vindictively

Validity of consent--a review of statutes.

In recent years there have been a number of malpractice suits based on lack of consent or inadequate consent from the patient for the procedure used in treatment. This is a particularly dangerous suit for the doctor since the burden of proof lies on the doctor. Furthermore since the suit is based on intentional assault, some insurance policies do not cover the doctor for his liability. The common meaning of consent is permission, whereas the law perceives it as a contract i.e. an agreement enforceable by law. So a doctor needs to understand the legal basis of consent rather than the common meaning of it. The present article aims to discuss the various legal aspects of consent as viewed in the Indian law.